Sign Up for Updates

Williams-Sonoma Amazon Lawsuit

Williams-Sonoma Trademark Suit Against Amazon Can Proceed, Federal Judge Says

05-13-2019

A federal district court judge rejected Amazon’s bid to dismiss Williams-Sonoma’s trademark infringement suit against it, ruling there was a “plausible inference” that Amazon was “cultivating the incorrect impression” with consumers that it was an authorized reseller.

U.S. District Judge Elizabeth Laporte, San Francisco, in a ruling released Thursday, found that Amazon’s “Shop by Williams-Sonoma” webpage used copyrighted pictures and product images and was “likely to confuse” consumers.

“At a minimum, Williams-Sonoma has sufficiently alleged that Amazon acted with an ‘aura of indifference’” to the rights under the [Williams-Sonoma] trademark in deliberately it in ads and website content to imply “a non-existent affiliation” with Williams-Sonoma, Laporte ruled.

At the same time, she said her decision was a “close call,” noting that the Amazon logo and search bar were at the top of Shop by Williams Sonoma product pages and that users were asked to “Try Prime” — a reference to the Amazon Prime service. Laporte also acknowledged that Amazon’s motion raised legitimate questions and that allegations that it set up an unauthorized Williams-Sonoma website were “not plausible.”

Contacts:

Amazon, David Zapolsky, General Counsel, 206-266-1000 Williams-Sonoma, David Randolph King, General Counsel, 415-421-2900

Become a Member Today

Learn More

  • Copyright © 2019 Licensing International
  • We use web cookies to offer you a better experience on our site. By clicking on "Accept" you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.

    Translation provided by Google Translate, please pardon any shortcomings